Strong Female Characters – If I’m to be completely honest: Part 1

26 Aug

I’m going to start out by saying that I’m odd.

I could talk about how I used to play video games, my inspirations for writing came from the old-school style pulp science fiction novels, but that’s really window dressing.

My reasoning for the disclaimer is that my Myers-Briggs Profile is INTJ – and as a female, this is the second least-common personality profile in the population. It’s not a bad thing; common INTJ traits often lead the vast majority of the population to think we’re highly intelligent when in all reality, it’s more of ‘I’m only going to show you what I’m good at when I’m good at it.” I know some people get arrogant when they’re intelligent, but I’m going to throw out this nugget: Generally smart people don’t feel the need to remind you all the time. And the smartest ones are probably aware there’s plenty that they don’t know, but that’s a rant for another time.

I also work in a male dominated field – our typical INTJ is probably doing something very studious, high tech or in a position of leadership. I currently work on a rare ‘broad squad’ of everyone in my paramedic rotation being female, but that’s neither here nor there – there are lots of women medics pushing retirement, so we’re really not that special, other than the sheer concentration of us on our platoon. As a rule, I’d say more career (in other words, those not doing the job as they study towards medicine or whatever) are probably the more guardian-personality types then the straight up rationalists. Of course, you have to be a bit of an odd personality to thrive in EMS, so we got a mix of everyone. This discussion isn’t about our sick sense of humour.

The point of the last two paragraphs is 1) I have an uncommon personality type – even more rare for women and 2) I do a typically male-dominated job. I don’t expect a lot of people – especially women – to see things my way. On point, with that personality and that job, don’t expect me to care.

Part 1: Beyond the Mindless Violence of Hack and Slash Adventure

If we were to think of the stereotypical ‘strong female character’ I’m probably the worst example, at least when I started, because my earlier works were inspired by a lot of Burroughs adventures, but it wasn’t just the old paperbacks inherited through my father. I can point to lots of sources. I’m going to blame my dad’s old Marvel Comic’s Version of Belit.

We could analyze about the white woman ordering about her black pirates, but I’m going to take this moment to point out she’s Shemite – or Semetic.

Belit wasn’t the only one – here’s a slew of some of the stuff I was engrossed with growing up.

Science-fiction and fantasy has a huge advantage in the made-up or alternative timelines that you can make the rules what you want so long as you’re consistent. If your hero is super-powered, it really doesn’t matter if your hero gets superpowers and he’s a big brawny bad ass or a little tiny kitten. Granted, most people outside the vein will probably think things like gender and racial discrimination to be more interesting than save the made up kingdom, but when you’re a kid you just want your characters to be active. You want to get to know the princess, not have her hang out and wait while the boys go out and have all the fun. Can you blame the boys for the ‘no girls allowed’ club house rules? No – but at some point, puberty hits and you start to discover you like some of the same stuff.

And hey wait a minute… Belle’s not a warrior… and Anne Shirley’s a romantic heroine wannabe, what is she doing on this list?

Like I said: when I was growing up, I liked my characters to be active.

If we were to look at characters on the whole, the heroes are usually acting out against something more powerful than they are – not necessarily man vs man as in hero versus villain, but if there’s no plot, we’re dabbling dangerously close to experimental literature, which I will only reference tongue-in-cheek. For me, I didn’t mind if a character was a complete victim and had a problem thrown on them, so long as they were active in trying to solve the issue. As I became a more mature reader, it mattered less to me that the character embodied strength and was a general badass, but that the struggle was real.

The thing about female characters is that, in general (painting with broad strokes) that they encompass the role of David up against Goliath inherently – whether we consider this in general physical capabilities or even history in context. In Game of Thrones, it’s easy to love Arya as she’s struggling against what society deems appropriate for her – if she grows up to be the most overpowered blademaster in all of fiction, the story starts out when she’s 9 or 10 (It’s been a few years, sorry). In that same vein easy to dismiss Sansa as a traditional princess archetype and going along with an unjust society to her advantage because she embraces the role society thrusts on her. Things change real quick and both these girls have a different skillset for handling their situations. These two characters might rise to power, but when we start out, they’ve got the most to grow. I could argue that is the appeal of YA literature – these are characters who start out relatively powerless in society, and have to come to grips with their place in it. Yes, it is fun to read stories about Johnny Quest who gets to do everything because he’s hanging out with his scientist father and he doesn’t have to worry about the cost of various hoverbikes, men shooting up ski equipment and trips to exotic locations, or that Tintin probably has serious cranial injuries by now. Depending on how much escapism is desired, someone young, who might not own their own property, they might prove inherently more interesting to follow around then an overpowered warrior unless the warrior is doing something he’s not used to or the stakes are that much higher. Point is, if the stakes get too high and we can’t relate, the struggle becomes less real for the audience.

But we don’t have to look only to science fiction and fantasy to see “strong female characters”. In Pride and Prejudice we don’t want Elizabeth to marry Mr. Darcy just because he’s the right man for her – we want them to come to each other on equal footing. Elizabeth needs more than just financial security, she needs a partner who will regard her at the same level as he is.

And this is not to say that women are always weaker or have been victims. If we take for granted that it’s hard to get a place in the history books, I can point you out to Bouddica, Sun Shangxiang, Empress Theodora (think Bryzantine Era), Eleanor of Aquitaine…

Anyway, as a writer my fiction got more sophisticated and I started to learn more about general trauma, I learned that fighting is exciting, but it doesn’t always suit a story that the characters solve things by physical fighting. I don’t mind it, but sometimes the danger in the villain is that they are so overpowered, that physically overpowering them isn’t really the climax of the story. If the villain is also much more clever then the hero but the hero manages to put his two brain cells together to stop the villain’s plan, it can be way more interesting then necessarily sending Superman in to stomp Lex Luthor.

Sure – it’s cool to watch Legolas be the most badass thing in history. I’m sure none of you were with me, watching a certain trilogy of sequels and biting back their laughter in the theatre because they’re looking for new ways to make him look great, and that physics is just an option.

(Fantasy isn’t supposed to be realistic! I know, I know…)

A character doesn’t need to be the most physically strong to be strong in character. I think we all take this statement for granted but I think this is a good bit to bring up before I talk about specifics.

In Part 2, we’ll get to Oppression Genres – the Good, the Bad, and the WTF.

2 Responses to “Strong Female Characters – If I’m to be completely honest: Part 1”

  1. Holly Geely August 26, 2015 at 5:12 pm #

    I look forward to part 2 🙂

    Oh, Pirates of Dark Water. How I wish they’d finished it!

    • ltgetty August 26, 2015 at 11:50 pm #

      I loved that cartoon growing up!

      Unfortunately, I’m a bit under the weather today, so I’m not working on part 2 right now, but I’ve already got a chunk of it done. There’s so much to say about this topic, and I kept going into mini rants, that I had to break it down into parts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: